February 14, 2011 - Regular Meeting - Minutes



School Board of Manatee County
215 Manatee Avenue West
Bradenton, FL 34205
www.manateeschools.net
Regular Meeting - 5:45 p.m.

Times Indicated Are Approximate


AGENDA AMENDMENTS (5:45 p.m.)
1. Agenda Amendments - p.6

ATTENDANCE (5:45 p.m.)
2. Attendance - p.7

Minutes: 

Board members present: Robert C. Gause, Chairman; Harry G. Kinnan, Vice-Chairman; Julie B. Aranibar, Karen Carpenter, and Barbara A. Harvey. Also present: Tim McGonegal, Superintendent; Lynette Edwards, Assistant Superintendent for Curriculum and Instruction; Darcy Hopko, Assistant Superintendent for District Support Services; Jim Drake, Assistant Superintendent for Business Services; Scott Martin, Staff Attorney; and John Bowen, School Board Attorney.


CALL TO ORDER (5:45 p.m.)
3. Call to Order - p.8

Minutes: 

Chairman Gause called the meeting to order at 5:45 p.m.

4. Color Guard - Manatee High School - p.9
5. Pledge of Allegiance - p.10

Minutes: 

Chairman Gause led in the recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance.

6. Star Spangled Banner

Minutes: 

"The Star Spangled Banner" was performed by the Haile Middle School Swing Choir under the direction of Ms. Sarah Davis.

7. Invocation - p.11

Minutes: 

The Invocation was given by Rev. Gene Brock, Samoset Full Gospel Tabernacle.

8. Approval of Orders of the Day - p.12
Attachment: Agenda Item - Approval of Plan to Comply with Class Size.pdf
Attachment: 2010-11 Compliance Plan Template - Manatee.pdf
Attachment: Addendum for February 14, 2011.pdf
Attachment: Star Spangled Banner.pdf
Attachment: W020711.pdf
Attachment: W020911.pdf
Attachment: Agenda Item - Career and Technical Education Month.pdf
Minutes: 

The Chair found good cause to amend the agenda to include all items listed under Agenda Amendments on the February 14, 2011 Agenda, updated February 11, 2011 and posted to the district website, www.manateeschools.net, as follows:

Agenda amended on February 11, 2011, to add Call to Order item Star Spangled Banner.

Agenda amended on February 11, 2011, to add a recipient to Recognition item Career and Technical Education Month Presentation.

Agenda amended on February 11, 2011, to attach the minutes of the Board Workshop of February 7, 2011 and the Board Workshop of February 9, 2011.

Agenda amended on February 11, 2011, to attach Addendum to Consent item Approval of the Appointments, Change of Assignments, Deceased, Promotions, Reappointments, Reassignments, Recommendations for Professional Service Contracts, Resignations, Retirements, Terminations and Transfers.

Agenda amended on February 8, 2011, to add New Business Item Approval of  Plan to Comply with Class Size for the 2011-2012 Fiscal Year.



Motions:

Motion and approval of the orders of the day as amended.

- PASS
 
Vote Results
Motion: Harry Kinnan
Second: Barbara Harvey
Julie Aranibar- Aye
Karen Carpenter- Aye
Robert Gause- Aye
Barbara Harvey- Aye
Harry Kinnan- Aye


STUDENT CELEBRATION (5:49 p.m.)
9. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Speech Contest Winners - p.13

Minutes: 

Lynette Edwards, Assistant Superintendent for Curriculum and Instruction, introduced this item to the Board.

Ms. Edwards invited Ms. Patricia Johnson, Palmetto Youth Center board member, to give the School Board an overview of this item.  She announced the middle and high school winners of the speech contest, and invited the students to present their winning speeches to the Board.

Madelyn Kumar from Nolan Middle School and Dakota Lawson from Southeast High School each delivered their speech to the Board.


PUBLIC COMMENTS (6:00 p.m.)
10. Public Comments - p.14

Minutes: 

Linda Schaich - expressed concern about the district's health insurance fund.

Peggy Delegato - invited the Board Members to attend the Martin Luther King, Jr. Commemorative Breakfast, taking place on Saturday, February 19, 2011, at the Palmetto Youth Center.

Dave Miner - highlighted several historic individuals in honor of Black History Month.  He thanked the Superintendent for placing the district checkbook on the district website.

Eileen Jones - spoke in support of SEA (Suspension Education Alternative) program, and Bridge of Hope.  She described the program, which is for students that have been suspended, and encouraged Board support of the program.

Peggy Martin - expressed concern about the district's health insurance fund.

Kimberly Lough - expressed concern about proposed changes to the district's field trip policy, which would result in reducing approved providers for student field trips.


APPROVAL OF MINUTES (6:15 p.m.)
11. Approval of Minutes - p.15
Attachment: M012411.pdf
Attachment: W020711.pdf
Attachment: W020911.pdf

Motions:

Motion and approval of the Regular Meeting of January 24, 2011, Workshop of February 7, 2011, and Workshop of February 9, 2011.

- PASS
 
Vote Results
Motion: Karen Carpenter
Second: Julie Aranibar
Julie Aranibar- Aye
Karen Carpenter- Aye
Robert Gause- Aye
Barbara Harvey- Aye
Harry Kinnan- Aye


RECOGNITIONS (6:18 p.m.)
12. Career and Technical Education Month Presentation - p.16
Attachment: Proclamation.pdf
Minutes: 

Doug Wagner, Director of Adult, Career, and Technical Education, introduced this item to the Board.

He invited William Tillett, Esperanza Gamboa, Debra Smith, Cheryl McGrew, and Kimberly Lough to read portions of the Proclamation and to speak about the various Career and Technical Education awards they have received.

13. Academic Industry Certification Funding Recognitions - p.17

Minutes: 

Doug Wagner, Director of Adult, Career, and Technical Education, introduced this item to the Board.  He described the various CAPE (Career and Professional Education) Academies in the district.

Mr. Wagner invited Angie Grasberger, Coordinator of Small Learning Communities, to the podium to present checks to principals and academy lead teachers from Bayshore High School, Braden River High School, Manatee High School, Lakewood Ranch High School, and Palmetto High School.

The Board congratulated and thanked Mr. Wagner for providing excellent programs for Manatee County students.


REPORTS AND PRESENTATIONS (6:30 p.m.)
14. Manatee Education Foundation Update - p.19

Minutes: 

Mary Glass, Director of the Manatee Education Foundation (MEF), introduced Chairman of the MEF Board of Directors, Debra Cooper.

Ms. Cooper introduced the members of the MEF Board who were in attendance at the meeting.  She also recognized Ms. Tricia McKay May, Development Director of the MEF.

Ms. Cooper and Ms. Glass updated the Board on the activities of the MEF, which benefit students and teachers.

15. Central Florida School Boards Coalition - p.20

Minutes: 

Mrs. Harvey updated the Board on the meeting of the Central Florida School Boards Coalition, which took place earlier in the day.


CONSENT ITEMS (6:40 p.m.)
Approval of Consent Agenda

16. Approval of February 14, 2011 Consent Agenda - p.21

Minutes: 

The Chair found good cause to amend the agenda to include all items listed under Agenda Amendments on the February 14, 2011 Agenda, updated February 11, 2011 and posted to the district website, www.manateeschools.net, as follows:

Agenda amended on February 11, 2011, to attach Addendum to Consent item Approval of the Appointments, Change of Assignments, Deceased, Promotions, Reappointments, Reassignments, Recommendations for Professional Service Contracts, Resignations, Retirements, Terminations and Transfers.



Motions:

Motion and approval of the Consent Items as amended.

- PASS
 
Vote Results
Motion: Harry Kinnan
Second: Barbara Harvey
Julie Aranibar- Aye
Karen Carpenter- Aye
Robert Gause- Aye
Barbara Harvey- Aye
Harry Kinnan- Aye

Purchase(s) Bids $100,000.00 and Under

17. Approval of Bid on Lift Station and Grease Trap Services, MCSD No. 11-0033-MR - p.22
Attachment: 110033BL.pdf
Attachment: 110033t.pdf
18. Approval of Bid on Fire Alarm Inspections and Repairs, MCSD No. 11-0035-MR - p.24
Attachment: 110035BL.pdf
Attachment: 110035BL PART 2.pdf
Attachment: 110035t.pdf
Purchase(s) Bids Over $100,000.00

19. Approval of Renewal (2) on the Use of State of Florida Contract on Office Furniture and Files, MCSD No. 06-0119-ML - p.26
20. Approval of Renewal (2) on the Use of the School Board of Sarasota County Bid on Hollow Metal Doors, MCSD No.09-0079-MR - p.27
21. Approval of Renewal (1) on Aquatic Control Services, MCSD No. 10-0044-MR - p.28
Contracts and Grants

22. Approval of the SuccessMaker and Waterford Renewal Support Between the School Board of Manatee County and NCS Pearson, Inc., for the 2010 - 2011 School Year - p.29
Attachment: Success Maker and Waterford Renewal.pdf
23. Approval of the Contract Between the School Board of Manatee County and Robert Dorn Consultants for the 2010 - 2011 School Year - p.31
Attachment: Robert Dorn Consultants - March-June 2011.pdf
Construction Services

24. Approval of Manatee High School - Davis Building Replacement - Culinary Arts Lab - Substantial Completion - p.33
Attachment: MHS Davis Summary Sheet.pdf
Attachment: MHS Davis Bldg Substantial Completion Culinary Arts Lab and Punchlist.pdf
25. Approval of Myakka City Elementary School - Renovation - Substantial Completion - Phase 2B - Building 3 and Courtyard 3 Drainage Improvements - p.34
Attachment: Myakka City Summary Sheet.pdf
Attachment: Myakka City Substantial Completion - Ph2B-Bldg3-Courtyard3Drainage Improvements.pdf
26. Approval of Palmetto High School - Additions and Renovations - Change Order 5 - Final - Agreement Between Owner and W. G. Mills, Inc. - p.35
Attachment: Palmetto High Summary.pdf
Attachment: PHS CM C.O. 5-Final-form.pdf
27. Approval of Southeast High School - Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning Upgrades and Renovations - Culinary Arts Lab - Substantial Completion - p.36
Attachment: Southeast HS HVAC Upgrades and Renov - Summary Sheet.pdf
Attachment: SEHS HVAC Substantial Comp Culinary Arts Lab and Punchlist.pdf
Finance

28. Approval of the Year to Date Financial Statements through December 2010 - p.37
Attachment: FS Dec 2010.pdf
Human Resources

29. Approval of the Appointments, Change of Assignments, Deceased, Promotions, Reappointments, Reassignments, Recommendations for Professional Service Contracts, Resignations, Retirements, Terminations and Transfers - p.38
Attachment: Resume - Evon Nelson.pdf
Attachment: Resume - Cynthia Maynepdf.pdf
Attachment: Addendum for February 14, 2011.pdf
Attachment: Board Material 02-14-11.pdf

INFORMATION
Leaves

30. Leaves for February 14, 2011 Board Meeting - p.39
Attachment: Leaves - 02-14-11.pdf

ADMINISTRATIVE APPOINTMENTS
31. Appointments - p.40

OLD BUSINESS
NEW BUSINESS (Discussion Items Pulled from Consent)
NEW BUSINESS (Non-Consent Items) (6:43 p.m.)
32. Approval of the 2011 - 2012 Academic Calendar - p.41
Attachment: 2011-12 Calendar Committee Members.pdf
Attachment: 2011-2012 Spring Break March Calendar.pdf
Attachment: 2011-2012 Spring Break April Calendar.pdf
Minutes: 

Superintendent McGonegal introduced this item to the Board.  He described the process used to arrive at the recommended academic calendar.  Superintendent McGonegal noted that either calendar was acceptable, but that his recommendation was the 2011 - 2012 Spring Break April Academic Calendar.

The Board held discussion prior to voting on this matter.

The Board asked the Superintendent to restate his recommendation.  He said that his recommendation was the 2011 - 2012 Spring Break April Academic Calendar.

There was not a motion in support of the Superintendent's recommendation.

Chairman Gause asked the Superintendent if he would like to change his recommendation.

The Board held discussion about the best way to address the question.

Superintendent McGonegal changed his recommendation to approval of the 2011 - 2012 Spring Break March Academic Calendar.



Motions:

Motion and approval of the 2011 – 2012 Spring Break March Academic Calendar.

- PASS
 
Vote Results
Motion: Barbara Harvey
Second: Julie Aranibar
Julie Aranibar- Aye
Karen Carpenter- Aye
Robert Gause- Aye
Barbara Harvey- Aye
Harry Kinnan- Aye

33. Approval of Second Amendment to Agreement Between the School Board of Manatee County and Timothy McGonegal for the Services of Superintendent of Schools - p.43
Attachment: McGonegal - Second Amendment to Agreement.pdf
Minutes: 

Superintendent McGonegal introduced this item to the Board.



Motions:

Motion and approval of second amendment to Agreement between the School Board of Manatee County and Timothy McGonegal for the services of Superintendent of Schools.

- PASS
 
Vote Results
Motion: Harry Kinnan
Second: Barbara Harvey
Julie Aranibar- Aye
Karen Carpenter- Aye
Robert Gause- Aye
Barbara Harvey- Aye
Harry Kinnan- Aye

34. Approval of Plan to Comply with Class Size in the 2011-2012 Fiscal Year
Attachment: 2010-11 Compliance Plan Template - Manatee.pdf
Minutes: 

Superintendent McGonegal introduced this item to the Board.

Chairman Gause noted that, particularly in the elementary grades, the district will be implementing multi-grade classrooms.  He asked for the Superintendent's assurance that teachers instructing in that environment will receive special training in how to effectively teach multi-grade classrooms.

Superintendent McGonegal assured the Chairman that the training will be given.  In addition, he noted that multi-grade classrooms are not the preference of the district, unless they are in the best educational interests of the students.  He said that there have been several multi-grade classrooms in the district in the past, and there will be more in the future.  He explained that this step will be necessary to meet the requirements of the Class Size Amendment.

Ms. Aranibar reported that her children have participated in multi-grade classrooms in the past, with both positive and negative results.



Motions:

Motion and approval of the plan to comply with class size in the 2011-2012 fiscal year.

- PASS
 
Vote Results
Motion: Harry Kinnan
Second: Julie Aranibar
Julie Aranibar- Aye
Karen Carpenter- Aye
Robert Gause- Aye
Barbara Harvey- Aye
Harry Kinnan- Aye


BOARD COMMENTS (7:00 p.m.)
35. Board Comments - p.44

Minutes: 

Mr. Kinnan

 

Take Stock in Children  - kudos to all involved in planning the Leadership Prayer Breakfast, which was held on February 3, 2011.

 

Support Employee of the Year Celebration - noted that all district employees are involved in education of children.  He said this was a great event.  He congratulated every individual that was nominated by their work site.

 

Board Workshops - said that the previous week's Board Workshops, regarding Charter Schools and Audit Findings, were very useful and informative.

 

Ms. Carpenter

 

Black History Month - said she read in the Bradenton Times that in the 1940's, Frances Stevens sued the Manatee County School Board over different pay scales for African American and Caucasian teachers, and that she won her lawsuit.

 

Ms. Aranibar

 

Williams Elementary School - visited the school and addressed the School Advisory Council (SAC) recently.

 

Freedom Elementary School - said she will be visiting this school soon.

 

Transportation - thanked Superintendent McGonegal for scheduling the meeting with the bus drivers, which occurred on February 11, 2011.

 

Budget Committee - reported that the Budget Committee would meet on Tuesday, February 15, 2011, and Wednesday, February 16, 2011.  She thanked community members for providing input into the process.

 

Mrs. Harvey

 

Take Stock in Children  - attended the Leadership Prayer Breakfast.

 

Kelly-Brown Career Center Opening - thanked all community members who attended ribbon cutting.  She noted that Connect Your Community computer classes will be held at that facility, beginning in March.

 

Future Business Leaders - attended the opening ceremony for this event on February 4, 2011.  She said the middle and high school students were spellbound by the speaker at this event.

 

Tim McGonegal - congratulated the Superintendent on receiving his doctorate degree.

 

Mr. Gause

 

Valentine's Day - wished everyone a Happy Valentine's Day.

 

District Checkbook - commended the Superintendent and Finance Department staff for placing the district checkbook on the district website.

 

CEO Roundtable - reported that he attended this meeting on Friday, February 11, 2011.  He said that Sheriff Steube made a presentation about what his office is doing to reduce gang activity in the county.

 

State Board of Education - noted that the State Board of Education would hold their meeting at the State College of Florida Collegiate School on Tuesday, February 15, 2011.  He said he would plan to attend that event.

 

Budget - addressed some myths and facts about preparation of the district budget.  He thanked employees who have expressed to him that they understand the current budget difficulties, and encouraged the Board as they prepare the budget.  He noted that ultimately the Board will make decisions that are right for students.


SCHOOL BOARD WORKFLOW (7:20 p.m.)
36. School Board Workflow Items - p.45

SCHOOL BOARD ATTORNEY COMMENTS (7:22 p.m.)
37. Comments by John Bowen - p.46

Minutes: 

Mr. John Bowen

 

Mr. Bowen had no comments. 


SUPERINTENDENT'S REPORT (7:25 p.m.)
38. Comments by Tim McGonegal - p.47

Minutes: 

Mr. Tim McGonegal

 

District Budget - thanked Chairman Gause for his comments regarding preparation of the district budget.  He expressed that the way Manatee County School District conducts the budget process is the right way for the community, employees, and students.

 

Lynette Edwards - the Board and Superintendent surprised Lynette Edwards, Assistant Superintendent for Curriculum and Instruction, with a birthday cake.


ADJOURNMENT (7:30 p.m.)
Executive Session

39. Executive Session - p.48

Minutes: 

Mr. John Bowen, School Board Attorney, requested an Executive Session regarding pending litigation to which the School Board is presently a party before a court or administrative agency. 

Chairman Gause announced that those in attendance would be Board Members Julie B. Aranibar, Karen Carpenter, Robert C. Gause, Barbara A. Harvey, Superintendent Tim McGonegal, School Board Attorney John Bowen, Staff Attorney Scott Martin, and a court reporter. He said the estimated length of the Executive Session would be approximately 30 minutes.

Chairman Gause recessed the meeting at 7:51 p.m.

Mr. Kinnan did not participate in the Executive Session, and exited the building.

Chairman Gause reconvened the meeting at 8:12 p.m.

Adjournment of Meeting (8:00 p.m.)

40. Adjournment - p.49

Minutes: 

There being no further business to come before the Board, Chairman Gause adjourned the meeting at 8:12 p.m.

 

 

 

_______________________________           _______________________

Tim McGonegal,  Ex Officio Secretary              Robert C. Gause,

and Superintendent of Schools                       Chairman



NOTICE
Any person who desires to appeal any decision made by the School Board with respect to any matter considered at the above-mentioned meeting will need a record of the proceedings, and for such purpose may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which an appeal may be based. School Board meetings are held in accessible locations. Auxiliary aids will be provided, upon written request received at least 48 hours prior to the meeting, to participants with disabilities.